The Best Pizza in Manhattan: A Guide to Finding Your Perfect Slice
Finding the perfect pizza in Manhattan can be a bit of a challenge, but don’t worry—we’ve got you covered. Pizza is an art, a science, and a guilty pleasure that’s as universally beloved as it is universally divisive. But here’s the thing: when you’re in New York City, pizza isn’t just a food—it’s a lifestyle. It’s a conversation starter, a comfort food, and often the center of a casual or special occasion. And if you’re looking for the best pizza in Manhattan, you’re in luck.
1. Brooklyn: The Neighborhood Where Pizzas Are Born
Brooklyn is the birthplace of pizza in America, and for good reason. This borough is home to some of the most iconic pizza joints in the city, and it’s a testament to how much the neighborhood has grown and evolved. From classic New York-style crusts to innovative toppings, Brooklyn offers a diverse menu of pizza options.
For example, Papa John’s New York has been making pizza since 1955, and their wood-fired crust is a must-try. But don’t miss the hidden gem Bella Italia, a family-owned spot that’s been serving up delicious wood-fired pizzas for decades. Here’s the thing: when you’re in Brooklyn, you’re not just eating pizza—you’re experiencing the art of making it.
2. The Upper West Side: Where Comfort Meets Tradition
If you’re looking for a slice of pizza that’s as comfortingly familiar as your morning latte, chances are you’ll find it in the Upper West Side. This area is known for its cozy, family-friendly restaurants that prioritize comfort and quality.
One of the best pizza spots here is Joe’s Pizza. This small, family-owned joint has been serving up wood-fired pizzas for decades, and their secret is in the dough. The thick, almost pie-like crust is perfectly balanced, allowing the toppings to shine. Here’s the kicker: you can have a drink while you eat, which is a true NYC experience.
3. Greenpoint: Where Pizza Meets Culture
Greenpoint is a neighborhood that’s all about mixing tradition with creativity, and pizza is no exception. This Brooklyn neighborhood is home to some of the most unique and interesting pizza places in the city, all while maintaining that classic pizza flavor.
One spot that really stands out is Divina Pizza. This place is known for its unconventional toppings, like fresh mozzarella, heirloom tomatoes, and even truffle oil. But don’t be afraid to go old-school—they still serve classic Italian slices that are perfectly balanced and oh-so-delicious.
4. Williamsburg: Where Art Meets Flavor
If you’re looking for a pizza that’s as unique as the neighborhood that created it, Williamsburg is the place to go. This Brooklyn neighborhood is all about reinvention, and its pizza scene is no exception.
Here’s where you’ll find Artisanal Pizza Company. This spot is known for its focus on using locally grown ingredients, which gives the pizza a more vibrant and authentic flavor. They also offer a variety of creative toppings, like truffle-infused mozzarella and salted almond crusts. And if you’re in the mood for something a bit more interactive, you can even make your own pizza at the counter!
5. The Financial District: Where Pizza Meets Modernity
For those who are up for a bit of a challenge, the Financial District is a great place to try something new. This area is home to some of the city’s most innovative and unique pizza places, all while maintaining that classic taste.
Here’s a spot to check out: Fratello. This place is known for its focus on using fresh, high-quality ingredients, and their pizza is no exception. The toppings are arranged artistically, and the crust is ultra-thin, giving you more crust and fewer calories. If that doesn’t do it for you, they also offer a variety of sides and drinks to keep the meal going.
Final Thoughts: Why These Pizzas Are the Best in Manhattan
Whether you’re in Brooklyn, the Upper West Side, Greenpoint, Williamsburg, or the Financial District, there’s something for everyone. These pizza spots are all about combining tradition with creativity, and they’re all here to help you find your perfect slice. So the next time you’re in Manhattan, don’t forget to stop by one of these top pizza spots—your taste buds will thank you.
Now go out there and find your perfect slice!